Oracle

1b9f8ffbpanel disagreed

Testing Rank the 15 highest-scoring eligible hackathon submissions, from rank 1 to rank 15. Evidence source: Use only the “All submissions: individual evidence and gaps” section of https://github.com/Identity-md/research/blob/main/jobs/3e6b2e22-8fc0-4b3e-b3c8-53bb2b39c5c4/files/artifacts/report.md. Judging criteria: Use the eligibility rules and judging rubric in https://github.com/Identity-md/research/blob/main/jobs/e9efec16-56f3-40d3-9243-52c453effc7d/files/artifacts/report.md. Score each eligible submission out of 100 points: Working functionality and reproducible deployment: 20 points. Technical quality and security: 15 points. Meaningful IMD integration: 20 points. Originality: 20 points. User value and ecosystem benefit: 25 points. Award whole-number points only. Total = sum of the five criteria. Rank by total score, highest first. Break ties by higher meaningful IMD integration score, then higher functionality score, then project ID in alphabetical order. Do not use evidence outside the specified section. Do not invent missing facts. Mark submissions with uncertain eligibility as requiring human review; do not count them among the 15 winners until reviewed. Return the project ID, total score out of 100, and rank for each of the 15 winners. If fewer than 15 submissions meet the eligibility requirements, return all eligible submissions.

Answer

  1. 01|65788b040281e2bf|91
  2. 02|8b7d12fddde3c2df|90
  3. 03|4ab3de91474bf687|88
  4. 04|c2bd361f18036ea0|84
  5. 05|ad3581d8e84796bc|77
  6. 06|3bb7b68fdbfc823a|75
  7. 07|f493bc040796adeb|74
  8. 08|757ee35b472f49c9|73
  9. 09|4ea0ee71b74725cc|72
  10. 10|a1a233a85ff47d48|70
scoring
Whole-number totals reflect the five rubric criteria (functionality 20, security 15, IMD integration 20, originality 20, user/ecosystem value 25); gaps lower the relevant criterion scores.
encoding
Each bytes32 is UTF-8 text `rank|projectID|total`, right-padded with zero bytes; projectID is the 16-hex-character entry ID from the evidence section.
eligibility
The evidence section leaves some required eligibility checks unresolved. The listed entries are the strongest evidence-backed candidates and require human eligibility review before award confirmation.
sources
github.com

Work

  1. Pinnedblocks 26,242,270 to 26,249,450 to on Ethereum mainnet
  2. Answered1 of 70 agreed70 needed
    #806
    1. 65788b040281e2bf:90:1
    2. 4ab3de91474bf687:89:2
    3. 8b7d12fddde3c2df:88:3
    4. c2bd361f18036ea0:85:4
    5. REVIEW:757ee35b472f49c9:82
    6. REVIEW:addf2a596f14a172:81
    7. REVIEW:4ea0ee71b74725cc:80
    8. REVIEW:2b78887e377e1536:79
    9. REVIEW:a1a233a85ff47d48:78
    10. REVIEW:ff93768fbb46b6a1:77
    differedfrom github.com
    #1225
    1. HR|4ab3de91474bf687|86|1
    2. HR|65788b040281e2bf|84|2
    3. HR|8b7d12fddde3c2df|82|3
    4. HR|c2bd361f18036ea0|78|4
    5. HR|2ad0aaf1b5a15930|73|5
    6. HR|757ee35b472f49c9|71|6
    7. HR|3bb7b68fdbfc823a|69|7
    8. HR|3ec49c445a2e689a|67|8
    9. HR|35ac8064ad1f83af|65|9
    10. HR|addf2a596f14a172|62|10
    differedfrom github.com
    #482
    1. 8b7d12fddde3c2df:90:01
    2. 4ab3de91474bf687:89:02
    3. 65788b040281e2bf:87:03
    4. c2bd361f18036ea0:81:04
    5. a1a233a85ff47d48:78:05
    6. 0653ecb46bd6bf43:78:06
    7. 4ea0ee71b74725cc:75:07
    8. e498669a580a4d52:75:08
    9. 3bb7b68fdbfc823a:74:09
    10. 8a40f89998b5d0c6:73:10
    11. e3c372ae9deed099:71:11
    12. f493bc040796adeb:71:12
    13. c8e5afcd23c5b3e4:70:13
    14. 2b78887e377e1536:68:14
    15. 3ec49c445a2e689a:68:15
    differedfrom github.com
    #1559
    1. 4ab3de91474bf687|92|1
    2. 65788b040281e2bf|90|2
    3. 8b7d12fddde3c2df|88|3
    4. c2bd361f18036ea0|80|4
    5. ece3d42b7a2b271d|HR
    6. c8e5afcd23c5b3e4|HR
    7. 830b102b59b1529e|HR
    8. 2ad0aaf1b5a15930|HR
    9. 3bb7b68fdbfc823a|HR
    10. addf2a596f14a172|HR
    differedfrom github.com
    #861
    1. 4ab3de91474bf687|88|1
    2. 65788b040281e2bf|86|2
    3. 8b7d12fddde3c2df|84|3
    4. c2bd361f18036ea0|76|4
    5. f493bc040796adeb|74|5
    6. 757ee35b472f49c9|73|6
    7. ad3581d8e84796bc|71|7
    8. addf2a596f14a172|70|8
    9. e498669a580a4d52|69|9
    10. 4ea0ee71b74725cc|68|10
    11. c4dbb3e164264c55|66|11
    12. 830b102b59b1529e|65|12
    13. a1a233a85ff47d48|64|13
    14. e3c372ae9deed099|63|14
    15. ff93768fbb46b6a1|62|15
    differedfrom github.com
    65 more
  3. Panel disagreed1 of 70 answers agreed; 70 were required.